Print - Close Window
X-Apparently-To: "Gerald Finnerty & Margie Dolan" <> via; Tue, 21 Aug 2007 07:53:50 -0700
X-Originating-IP: []
Return-Path: <>
Received: from (HELO ( by with SMTP; Tue, 21 Aug 2007 07:53:48 -0700
Received: (qmail 47581 invoked by uid 60001); 21 Aug 2007 14:53:47 -0000
DomainKey-Signature: a=rsa-sha1; q=dns; c=nofws; s=s1024;; h=X-YMail-OSG:Received:Date:From:Subject:To:Cc:In-Reply-To:
MIME-Version:Content-Type:Content-Transfer-Encoding:Message-ID; b=EW4g89q03UuUa8yVLFc6aIR1p/VURtZrgshK1R0Nc
X-YMail-OSG: hYzwV64VM1mVTvhzTn6J6L2covL.Rr_RpvZjnwm.Q35j6xEBMZX.5OEhFSHh7zvgdU392bF13hgpPeQWnVSKv40X7ibMQhTUn1
Received: from [] by via HTTP; Tue, 21 Aug 2007 15:53:47 BST
Date: Tue, 21 Aug 2007 15:53:47 +0100 (BST)
From: "William Finnerty" <>
Subject: Judge Laffoy has spoken of a "constitutional imperative" to protect Tara heritage sites
To: "Chief Justice John L. Murray" <>, "Brian Lenihan TD (Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform" <>, "Paul Gallagher S.C. (Attorney General, Republic of Ireland)" <>, "Mr James Hamilton (Director of Public Prosecutions, Republic of Ireland)" <>, "The Chief State Solicitor (Republic of Ireland)" <>, "Guardian of Republic of Ireland Constitution (President Mary McAleese)" <>, "Peter Sutherland (Former Attorney General, Chairman of Goldman Sachs International Bank, Steering Committee Member of the Bilderberg Group, and European Chairman of the Trilateral Commission)" <>, "Garda Commissioner Noel Conroy (Chief Commissioner of Police, Republic of Ireland)" <>, "Chief Constable Sir Hugh Orde OBE" <>
CC: "Northern Ireland Social Security Agency (Reference Disability Case Reference 52-82267 for YH615974D)" <>, "Nikiforos Diamandouros (The European Ombudsman) Case ref: 1867/2006/IP )" <>, "The Registrar, European Court of Human Rights, Council of Europe, Strasbourg. (Re: ECHR Case Reference: 25077/05)" <>, "Prime Minister Gordon Brown MP" <>, "Kathy Sinnott MEP, European Parliament Committee on Petitions" <>, "Dr. Bob Bowman, Lt. Col., USAF, ret." <>, "Susan Sheehan-Repasky" <>, "Jose Manuel Barroso (Lawyer & President of European Union Commission)" <>, "Marcin Libicki MEP (Chairman of European Parliament Committee on Petitions)" <>, "Radu Podgorean MEP (European Parliament Committee on Petitions)" <>, "Proinsias De Rossa MEP" <>, "Mairead McGuinness MEP" <>, "Stavros Dimas (Lawyer, and European Union Commissioner for Environment)" <>, "John Gormley TD (Green Party Leader & Minister for Environment, Heritage and Local Government)" <>, "US Senator Barack Obama (Constitutional/Civil Rights Lawyer & US Presidential Hopeful)" <>, "UNESCO World Heritage Centre (WHC)" <>, "World Monuments Fund" <>, "Europa Nostra, Pan-European Federation for Cultural Heritage (Mrs Sneška Quaedvlieg MihailoviŠ)" <>, "Dr Gerard Hogan (Senior Constitutional Lawyer, Fellow, Trinity College, Dublin)" <>, "Greg Nolan (Lawyer at Patrick Hogan & Co., Ballinalsloe, County Galway, Republic of Ireland)" <>, "Gerard J Madden (Senior Social Worker, Omagh, County Tyrone, Northern Ireland)" <>, "Adrian O' Kane (Lawyer at Patrick Fahy & Co, Omagh.)" <>, "Progressive Democrats Party Leader, Health Minister Mary Harney" <>, "Gerald Finnerty & Marjorie Dolan (New Inn, County Galway)" <>, "European Commission Representation in Ireland" <>, "Michael Farrell (Lawyer, Irish Human Rights Commissioner)" <>, "Patrick Cullinane" <>, "Willie Corduff, Rossport 5" <>, "Sir Anthony O'Reilly, Newspaper Proprietor" <>, "Fine Gael Party Leader, Enda Kenny" <>, "Transparency International Ireland" <>, "Jack Straw MP" <>, "Nancy Levant" <>, "Dr Garrett Fitzgerald (Chancellor of the National University of Ireland)" <>, "Law Society of Ireland" <>, "Former US President Bill Clinton" <>, "Josep Borrell Fontelles (President of the European Parliament)" <>, "Sinn Fein Party Leader, Gerry Adams MP" <>, "Clare Short MP (House of Commons, London)" <>, "Liam Aylward MEP" <>, "Dr Mark Clinton (Heritage Protection Alliance of Ireland Co-ordinator)" <>, "Macquarie Bank (PPP Financiers)" <>, "David Cameron MP (Leader of UK Opposition Party)" <>, "Rev Ian Paisley, Democratic Unionist Party" <>, "Labour Party Leader, Pat Rabbitte" <>, "Marie Murray (Senior Psychologist & Irish Times Columnist)" <>, "Irish Examiner Newspaper" <>, "The Law Society of England and Wales" <>, "Majella Mc Carron (Shell to Sea)" <>, "Eamon Ryan TD (Minister for Communications, Energy and Natural Resources" <>, "Sir Menzies Campbell QC MP" <>, "Phillip Inman, The Guardian" <>, "Suzon Forscey-Moore" <>, "Sky News" <>, "Ken Livingstone, Mayor" <>, "Irish Times Editor, Ireland" <>, "Julitta Clancy" <>, "Charlie Bird (RTE Chief News Correspondent)" <>, "Executive Intelligence Review" <>, "Nelson Mandela" <>, "Former President Mary Robinson (Ethical Globalization Initiative)" <>, "RTE (Republic of Ireland's National TV Station)" <>,, "Fianna Fail Party Leader, Prime Minister Bertie Ahern" <>, "Ciara Macklin (Lawyer, Fair & Murtagh)" <>, "Margot.Wallstrom (Vice President of EU Commission)" <>, "Dafydd Morgan" <>, "Meirion Bowen" <>, "Ashley Mote (Independent MEP for South East England Region)" <>, "MauriceKirk" <>, "President of the Council of the European Union (LuÝs Filipe Marques Amado)" <>, "Irish Embassy - London" <>, "Patrick M. Wood" <>, "Jacques Barrot (Vice-president of the European Commission with responsibility for Transport" <>, "Dr Paul Craig Roberts" <>, "Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe (Thomas Hammarberg)" <>, "Gearoid Geraghty (Lawyer, Fair & Murtagh, Ballinasloe)" <>, "Jim Allister MEP" <>,, "Liam Cashman (Environmental Directorate, The European Commission)" <>, "Minister Trevor Sargent TD (Green Party)" <>, "Venice Commission (Council of Europe)" <>,, "PatrickReynolds (Irish in Britain Representation Group)" <>, "Dr John Wilson" <>, "The Irish Council for Civil Liberties (ICCL)" <>, "Amnesty International UK" <>, "Irish Heritage Club (United States)" <>, "President George W. Bush" <>, "Ban Ki-moon (Secretary-General of the United Nations)" <>
In-Reply-To: <>
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: multipart/alternative; boundary="0-2045509869-1187708027=:46102"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit
Message-ID: <>
Content-Length: 13627

"Justice Laffoy had stated in her High Court opinion that there was in fact a 'constitutional imperative' to protect these assets."  

Nero fiddles while Rome burns?
by W. Finnerty.  Tue Aug 21, 2007 10:36
Vincent Salafia (Aug 20, 2007 21:24 above),
We have a situation at the present time whereby some of the most important heritage sites in the nation are under immanent threat of being badly damaged and/or COMPLETELY destroyed through the application of our National Monuments (Amendment) Act 2004, which many (including yourself apparently) believe is unconstitutional, or ILLEGAL in other words. (Some extremely important heritage sites have already been destroyed using this Act I understand.)
Yet, you apparently feel we should all be focussing on some lost or missing files that may (or may not?) be important at some later point in time. I hope you won't mind me saying this, and please note that I genuinely have no wish whatsoever to be offensive towards you, this approach does not seem at all appropriate to me. It's as if (from my viewpoint) somebody with two broken legs, and two broken arms, desperately needs your help, and you are advising them that the first and most important thing they should do is to have their teeth examined by a good dentist?
As I have already related above, constitutional law expert Dr Gerard Hogan (Fellow of Trinity College, Dublin), who was a member of your legal team in early 2006, also believes that our National Monuments (Amendment) Act 2004 is UNCONSTITUTIONAL. Please note again his statement in the January 14th 2006 Daily Telegraph article:
"Gerry Hogan, senior counsel for Mr Salafia, claimed the legislation used to push through the project was unconstitutional. He said the National Monuments (Amendment) Act 2004 weakened the role of the Oireachtas (Ireland's national parliament) by giving the minister discretionary powers to determine the fate of the country's heritage. Mr Hogan claimed the state's duty to protect monuments had been 'seriously compromised'." 
Also, I've had a look this morning at your Tara Watch PRESS RELEASE dated 29 July 2006, which I have reproduced below.
In view of all that's happened in the meantime, it seems to me that the contents of your press release below now raises a number of extremely important issues.
Consider, for example, the following sentence relating to the "Hill of Tara M3 Case":
"Justice Laffoy had stated in her High Court opinion that there was in fact a 'constitutional imperative' to protect these assets."
I (for one) couldn't agree more with Justice Laffoy; but, why I wonder has Justice Laffoy not been listened to by her colleagues in the judiciary?
It's also clear from the PRESS RELEASE text below that our Chief Justice, the Hon. Mr. Justice John Murray, has been heavily involved in all of this dark and messy business: which I personally find very scary.
Basically, the whole situation regarding the legality of our National Monuments (Amendment) Act 2004 appears to REMAIN full of major contradictions, doubts, and uncertainties: despite the EUROS 600,000 your case has cost the taxpayer. This, I believe is the issue that should now be receiving TOP PRIORITY by the whole nation; and until its legality is all properly sorted out, by the Supreme Court, I don't believe it is right for ANYBODY to be assuming this Act is legal. 
Neither do I believe that any of the Tara protestors should be tried in our courts of law until AFTER the Supreme Court has clearly decided on the heavily doubtful and disputed constitutionality of our National Monuments (Amendment) Act 2004.
29 July 2006
‘Chief Justice Postpones Setting Hearing Date for Hill of Tara M3 Case’
The setting of a hearing date in the Hill of Tara / M3 motorway case was postponed today by the Chief Justice, the Hon. Mr. Justice John Murray. He said he will set a hearing date after written submissions were received by The Attorney General, The Minister for the Environment, Meath County Council, and the National Roads Authority, due on 24th July.
Gerard Hogan, SC, Counsel for the Appellant, Mr. Vincent Salafia, asked for an early hearing date to be set, since he had given undertakings in the High Court that he would do so. 
Chief Justice Murray questioned whether there was any urgency in the case, since there is no injunction in place and no stoppage of works.
Counsel for Meath County Council argued that there as a “considerable shadow” hanging over the project in relation to the PPP (public private partnership) contract, which cannot be signed until the matter is through the courts.
This morning Chief Justice Murray also set a date of July 28th for delivery of judgment in the Carrickmines Castle case, which has been postponed a number of times already. The judgment in this case will have a significant impact on the Tara proceedings, since it will address whether or not there is a constitutional duty on the Government to protect the national heritage.
Justice Laffoy had stated in her High Court opinion that there was in fact a “constitutional imperative” to protect these assets.
Related Link:
The above text has been copied from the following Indymedia (Ireland) location:
For future reference purposes a copy of this e-mail will later today be placed at the following Internet address: 



For ideas on reducing your carbon footprint visit Yahoo! For Good this month.


              --- End of e-mail text ---


To be taken to the Front Page of this web site please click on the following link:


Constitution of Ireland:
Bunreacht na hEireann

and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment (United Nations): 


European Convention on Human Rights (Council of Europe):

Universal Declaration of Human Rights (United Nations): 




AltaVista        TRANSLATIONS        AltaVista  

     | Traductions | ▄bersetzungen | Traduzioni | Traduš§es | Traducciones |
| переводы | 翻訳  |  번역  |  
翻译 | Μεταφράσεις

  Please click on one of the National Flags to the left for translation into any of the languages represented.

For the full LIST of language translation facilities available please click on:



This web site is linked with: